Pairing: Poly!Hamilsquad x reader
Warnings: SMUT! Oral sex, fingering, loss of virginity (kinda), also another dirty thing at the end that I don’t want to physically write out, language, fluffy beginning, alcohol, translated French, terrible innuendos and an increasing amount of shameless writing
W o w, so I’m just gonna leave this here while I’m trying to come up with an ending to my next Laurens fic! I am struggling and it is way overdue, sooooo have this which I wrote like eight months ago? Anyways, this is literally just….like I see fics where it just focuses on Y/N when it’s going down and I- don’t look at me like that, I know you think about how it would go down to! I combined it so- nvm just…you’ll see. Sooo yeah…I should be ashamed with the vast amount of detail I think I added, but you know what, you dirty little fuckers have probably done worse! Give me some feedback and enjoy!
It was their five month anniversary, and Hercules just came home from work to find the table set with some food. He smiled and looked into the kitchen to find Y/N and John dancing to music. Lafayette was bobbing his head and picking out some wine.
Hands snuck around his waist and he felt a kiss against his back. “Happy anniversary, beloved,” Alex whispered in his ear and Herc turned around to give him a kiss.
“Happy anniversary,” He took off his shoes and ran to the bedroom real quick to change out of his clothes.
“Mon amours, you’re gonna burn the food,” Lafayette set out glasses on the table and looked to find Y/N and John still in their own little world.
“Guys, I’m not eating burnt lasagna,” Alex moves passed them and took the food out of the oven.
“My garlic knots!” Y/N races to the top oven and pulled the bread out, hearing Alex snicker. She punched his arm. “It’s not funny.“
"It is when it would’ve been your fault,” Alex smirked and went to sit at the table, Hercules coming out of the room with sweatpants and a lose t-shirt on.
“There you are,” John went over and gave him a passionate kiss. “Happy anniversary!” Lafayette made his way over and greeted the man the same.
Y/N came out of the kitchen, bowl in hand and sat down next to Herc and Alex, rubbing the formers leg and giving him a kiss.
Laf raised his glass and smiled, “Joyeux anniversaire, mon amours!” They all clinked glasses and smiled at each other.
They talked about their day, and how grateful they were that it was finally the weekend. They’ve been in their new apartment for two months, and while Herc still worked, the rest of them stayed at home most of the time.
“This is great, babygirl,” John said around a mouthful of salad, earning him a kick from Herc.
“Thanks, you helped,” Y/N stuck her third garlic knot into her mouth and got snickers from the boys. “Don’t test a girl and her bread.”
Once they were all done eating, Alex and Herc did the dishes, while Laf cleaned up the table. John and Y/N went to the couch and browsed for a movie to watch.
They decided on some Hugh Jackman movie none of them had seen, and about forty minutes in there was a graphic sex scene.
The couch groaned when Laf shifted in his seat. He was on one end, with Herc in the middle and Y/N on the other end. Alex was laying on John on the couch next to them, and suddenly Alex popped his head up and looked at John with a smirk.
“You want some help with that?” His whisper made John shiver, and he struggled to get into a sitting position.
“Wh-what, what do you mean?” John was getting nervous, avoiding eye contact with everyone, especially when he saw Y/N look over at the commotion.
“Dude, you’re hard,” Alex gave him his space, but still looked down at the obvious dick print on his pants. John flushed in embarrassment, making Alex speak softer, “There’s nothing wrong with that.”
They brought it up before. They’ve all been dating for five months, there was obviously an urge. They were all new to it, none of them knew where to start with having sex with five people at once. Laf had made some dirty comments that got Alex all hot and bothered, but John shyed away from the idea, saying it was too early. They all had an unspoken agreement that their first time had to be with everyone, together.
“It is a night of celebration,” Laf paused the movie, and looked towards the freckled boy. “And you’re obviously ready for a party.”
John blushed further at his predatory look, still not making eye contact. Herc ran a hand up Y/N’s thigh and it made her shift.
“We won’t force you, John, if that’s what you’re worried about,” Y/N looked at him sincerely. She obviously wanted to do it, but she wouldn’t want anyone to feel uncomfortable.
“No, I want to,” John finally looked up, taking a deep breath. “I do, trust me…”
Alex started kissing up his neck, and it made him get lost in thought.
“Then let’s get this party started,” Alex whispered in his ear and it made him whimper.
“I’m a virgin!” He decided to rip off the band aid, screaming out his fear.
It got quiet. John had his eyes closed, and his heart was beating rapidly. What if this was the breaking point?
“Okay,” Hercules got up from the couch and crouched in front of him, resting a hand over his cheek. John finally opened his eyes when Herc said, “Nothing wrong with that, either. We’ll go slow, if you’d let us?”
John glanced to see all the flustered looks turn into ones of understanding. "You’re…you guys aren’t upset?”
“Why would we be upset, babe?” Alex looked at him curiously. “There’s nothing wrong with being a virgin. Hell, I’m still a virgin some places.”
That made Y/N scratch her neck shyly, feeling her face heat up.
“We’ll go slow,” Herc took his hands in his, rubbing his thumb on the backside. “Is that okay?”
John looked around to see four people who loved him, who he loved.
“Okay,” John nodded, and then Herc was leading him into the bedroom. Behind them, Alex had pulled Y/N up, giving her a toe-curling kiss. It made Laf bite his lip and then Y/N was intertwining their fingers and pushing them towards the bedroom.
John and Herc were making out on the bed, and Laf snuck up behind John and started kissing his neck. Alex shut the door and wrapped his arms around Y/N, walking them over to their lovers.
“So, uh,” John scratches the back of his neck, looking at his partners. “How do we start this?”
“We’ll go slow,” Laf reminded him. “What do you want to do?“
John closed his eyes softly and thought it over. He didn’t want to do anything too far tonight, he didn’t want to get overwhelmed. Y/N sensed this and sat next to him on the bed.
"I wanna watch someone give you a blowjob,” She shrugged at Herc’s surprised look at her bluntness, but made John groan nonetheless. “Is that okay?”
“Yeah, hell yeah,” John grabbed her face and pulled her into a kiss.
Herc started undressing himself, watching Laf do the same. Y/N moves onto John’s neck, sucking a bruise onto his collar bone. Laf ran a hand up her backside and pulled at the hem of her shirt.
“Let me undress you, mon amours,” He sat up and pulled John’s shirt off him, taking in his broad chest and soft muscles. Him and Alex had the same kind of frame, and he’s seen both many times before, but never like this.
Herc ran his hand through Johns curls and tugged a little, noticing the wince of delight coming from him. Alex helped Y/N take her shirt off, smirking at the bra she wore.
“It’s nothing special,” She scoffed. Alex shook his head and kissed her.
“Doesn’t have to be,” He whispered against her lips. “You’re special enough.”
Laf pulled off her shorts as she sat up, running a hand slowly over her ass, looking up to see her softly bite her lip. He smirked and turned to see Herc watch hungrily.
“Now, I believe the lady asked to see a blowjob?” Alex sunk down on his knees, pulling John further down onto the bed. Laf got up and walked around, wanting to watch the show. Herc took his place and wrapped comforting hands around John’s upper body. Fingers wrapped around the hem of his boxers and tugged hesitantly.
“I’m gonna take these off, okay?” Alex looked up to see dark eyes, full of lust and anxiousness. John nodded and gasped as he pulled the fabric off slowly.
Y/N went over to Laf’s side, caressing his cheek with her blunt nails. They both watched Alex stroke John’s cock, pulling his foreskin back and watching precum leak from the tip.
Alex slowly licked up his base, and John moaned loudly, moving a hand up to cover his mouth.
“No, no,” Herc took his hand and intertwined it with his own. “None of that, we want to hear you.”
John felt goosebumps on his skin, feeling eyes on him. He looked up to see Laf and Y/N completely flustered.
Alex finally moved his mouth down, going about halfway down and hearing his boyfriend moan. He felt himself get uncomfortable with the restriction in his pants, and noticed that he was the only one fully dressed. But that would have to wait.
Herc snaked his hand around John’s chest and tugged at a nipple. He grew harder by the second at his moans and Alex’s mouth wrapped around his dick. Y/N squeezed her thighs together, and it didn’t go unnoticed. Laf smirked as she squirmed, caressing a hand over the back of thigh, making her shiver.
“Fuck, Alex,” John threw his head back against Herc’s chest, gasping as Alex took him fully into his mouth.
Soon enough, Alex was sucking hard, rubbing the inside of John’s thighs and licking around the tip. John’s eyes rolled into the back of his head as he let out a shuddering gasp and eventually came down his throat.
Laf rubbed himself through his boxers, and Y/N covered his hand with hers, earning a gasp from the man.
As Alex pulled his shirt over his head, John looked back and kissed Herc, moaning into his mouth. “I want to suck you.”
Herc quickly moved off the bed, kneeling one leg by John’s shoulder. He lowered his boxers to his thighs and John started stroking his cock, Herc groaning at the sensation.
"Y/N, come here,” Herc looked back and saw the girl looking completely overwhelmed. And she hasn’t even done anything but watch.
She got on all fours, facing Laf still, her backside to Herc, and John watched her underwear fold in as her legs bent.
“Take them off, babe,” He looked up and found Herc looking at him eagerly. John reached up with his free hand and pulled down her panties. She gasped and Laf stepped out of his own underwear. Alex was finally naked, too, stroking himself while watching the scene before him.
Y/N pulled Laf towards her and began to lick the tip of his cock, pulling at his ball sack and feeling Herc run a fingertip up her wetness.
Alex sighed as Laf pulled him over and got a hand on him, kissing behind his ear and moaning.
“Holy shit,” Y/N gasped as Herc put a finger in her, pulling off Laf and adjusting to the feeling. John’s eyes got wide as he saw his finger disappear into her, making a squelching sound.
Moans filled the room as they all tried to take in everything. Herc was holding back, trying not to fuck into Johns mouth. He had a hand on Herc’s ass and the other was stroking what he couldn’t hold in his mouth.
Y/N moaned around Laf and his face scrunched up in pleasure. He slurred to himself and kept the pace on Alex’s cock. Alex gripped his shoulder as he whispered how good Y/N’s mouth looked around Laf’s dick.
Herc sped up the pace, thrusting two fingers into her pussy at a speed that made her tremble. She fisted the sheets in her hands and bobbed her head quicker, trying to get Laf to release.
John was close, again. Hearing all the dirty noises that was coming from his partners did something to him. He loved the feeling of Herc on his tongue; he sucked harder and soon Herc was grabbing his hair and pulling out of his mouth. He stroked his cock fast, cumming on John’s chest with a grunt.
Alex watched with dark eyes, thrusting into Laf’s big hand and feeling his toe curls. Laf turned to give him a deep kiss, moving his hand faster.
Y/N had been neglected as Hercules bathed in the afterglow; but soon enough he put three fingers in her and focused on curling his fingers and making her cum only seconds later.
The vibrations against his cock made Laf finish in her mouth, some leaking out. That did it for Alex, watching her cheeks hallow and Laf’s semen leak down her chin. It was a complete sin.
Heavy breathing filled the room. Y/N pulled off and before she could wipe her chin, Alex leaned down and shoved his tongue into her mouth. It was something filthy; it made John’s eyes go wide when he saw Alex run his tongue over her jaw.
He got so lost in the sight that he startled when he felt a hand run over his hip. Laf looked down at him with a smirk, and proceeded to lick Herc’s cum off his chest.
“Shit,” John’s head fell back against the pillows and he let out a sigh. Herc moaned and sat down next to him.
Laf licked all the way up into John’s mouth, going slow and making him taste their lover.
Alex put his hand on Herc’s shoulder and gave him a deep kiss, “That’s hot.“
"Totally,” Herc looked up at him with complete love, holding onto the hand on his shoulder.
Y/N threw wet rags at them, alreayd having thrown on a nightshirt. “I’m not sleeping with sticky men.“
"Don’t worry, ma cheri,” Laf headed to the bathroom, looking her up and down as he said, “I got it all off.”
She rolled her eyes, but couldn’t help purse her lips. Herc was smirking and she threw a rag at his head.
Once they all cleaned up, they settled in bed, all throwing on new underwear.
Y/N had fell asleep as soon as she hit the bed, John snuggling close next to her, softly snoring. Laf was looking at something on his phone while Herc snuggled on the other side of John.
“That was fun,” Herc looked at the two sleeping with a smile. “Really fun…”
“That it was,” Alex pulled back his sheets and waited for Lafayette to come over and scoot towards Y/N. Alex cuddled behind the Frenchman and closed his eyes. “By the way, I’m totally fucking one of you next time.”
Laf laughed, “Funny you think you’re the one doing the fucking.”
“Yeah, Alex, you’re totally gonna be the one getting fucked,” Herc whispered and heard the man gasp in shock.
“Shhhh,” John reaches over and hit Herc in the chest, making the three giggle at his crankiness.
….🙈 okay let me know if you want to be tagged…