Arthur Morgan/Charles Smith/Reader smutty WIP
This story just needs a little tweaking, in the real world if you and your partner want to have a threesome it is best to discuss things before hand to work over boundaries however I didn’t write this that way because I just didn’t. Sorry. (Do not come to me for your sex education lol. The only thing I can tell you for certain is LUBE IS NECESSARY FOR ANAL SEX. )
I am pretty proud of my smut in this one.
You want to know what Charles’ cock is like and Arthur wants to see you take it.
*You can find ‘finished’ stories on my Ao3 account*
You and Arthur had been together for some time now, you got along well and were extremely compatible sexually, however there was one kink he was withholding from you. It wasn’t that he thought you would judge him or anything, it was more that he wasn’t sure how to approach it. Or even when to bring it up, until he overhears a tipsy conversation between you and Karen at the bar. The two of you were discussing Charles, or his dick size rather, with you leading the conversation.
“Listen, Arthur leaves me more than fulfilled but I can’t help but wonder what that big beautiful man is like in bed, God those big broad shoulders and those huge gentle hands just pinning you- ugh god stop-” you fan yourself cheeks going pink. “And I bet that cock is immaculate.”
“You should ask Arthur,” Karen offers.
“Ask Arthur what?”
“What Charles’ cock is like,” she scoffs like it's obvious.
“Oh, that would go well, Hey Artie, was just wondering what your ex’s cock was like for my own personal sexual fantasy reasons?” you roll your eyes. “Please he would never believe me the next time I tell him how irresistible or handsome he is. He will think I want to leave him or some shit, or that I think he’s ugly I don’t know. I just don’t want him getting the wrong idea, that I love him even a hair less than I do, because that would just devastate me Karen. Completely.” Arthur swallows against your words, heart swelling tight before he turns and walks off to find Charles.
“Charles?” You ask confused as you open the door. “But Arthur I thought that we were-” you turn to call back to him but he’s right behind you and your face hits his chest.
“Oh we are,” Arthur laughs in a way that sends chills down your spine as he turns you back to face Charles whose eyes are boring down onto you hungrily as he slowly steps into the entryway before he stops before you, towering. You feel your wetness grow and bite your lip as your face burns. “Or rather I was thinking… Charles could take care of you tonight.”
“If that’s okay with you,” Charles finally speaks as his eyes lock with yours. You can feel Arthur’s erection pressing against your ass and take that as all the reassurance that he is in fact into this before you nod.
“Are you ready Raindrop?” Charles voice rumbles down over you and you nod eagerly. “Okay, hold yourself open for me just like that,” your cheeks burn with arousal and a tinge of shame as you let him manipulate your hands so you are holding yourself open, glistening and trembling. He runs the head of his cock over your clit and down your slit a few times until you writhe. He presses in the head and your legs instinctively start to close. “Ah, ah,” he pushes in enough that he can let go of his member in favor of pushing your legs back open. “You want this?” you nod frantically and he smiles with a breath of a laugh. “Good, then be a good girl and hold yourself open for me.” He brings your fingers back down, that spark of shame running back through you as he makes you spread your pussy lips open. “That's it,” he leans forward cupping the back of your head so he can prop you up a little. “Look at that, look at how stretched out you are over my big fucking cock, fuck already, I don’t think that tight little cunt can take anymore.”
“No, no I can, I can,” you whine wiggling your hips but he stops you with a hand on your hip. He glances down at where his cock is slowly sinking into you before looking up and meeting your eye with a smoldering look. Without breaking contact he spits and you cry out in surprise when it lands on your clit. He hums pleased with himself and uses his thumb to rub it around your clit then up the rest of his cock before he resumes his steady push.
When he finally bottoms out, his hips flushed against yours you cry out a louder,
“Oh fuck!” It’s like your body has a mind of its own as you begin to frantically writhe and wriggle, your cunt trying to get used to the large unmoving intrusion inside of you, your heels failing to make purchase on the bed beneath you when your hands slip free.
“Look at those legs Arthur, can you see how bad they’re trembling?” he only wiggles a slight bit but various whines and gasps and moans and coos begin to fall from your lips. He revels in the dark crimson flush that has taken over your neck and cheeks, your hands scrambling at his back and shoulders each one of your small shifts causing teasing sparks of pleasure inside you. “Never been so full have you,” Charles laughs as you shake your head frantically, lips trembling in a whimper as you throw your head back into the blankets in an attempt to gain some leverage and create give between your body and his large, broad unmovable one. He shifts a little and you let out a sharp gasping moan. “Those sounds,” he growls, moving again, only a little in and out in and out. “Fuck you are so tight.” You can feel yourself growing wetter and wetter but he continues to tease and wait.
“Charles please,” you can feel your own juices dripping out of you at his game and he chuckles.
“Soon, soon, you just keep being a good girl and you will get everything you want and more.” At this he pulls out half way before sliding back in, after the third time you buck up forcing him back inside you with a loud cry, walls clenching around him. “Careful Missy I know what I’m doing you’ll get what you want.” You do it again though, a pleasurable pain hits you this time and he snarls. “Is this what you want?” he snaps and begins nailing into you hard and fast. Your limbs all go rigid and you kick and flail beneath him, it was too much too good all at once it was almost painful.
“Okay, okay,” you gasp out in a pained laugh as he slows back down to how he wanted it. “Okay.” you gasp one more time with another blissed out laugh.
“That is what I thought,” he smirks, then moves even slower now and you begin to writhe and whine harder and louder. He’s moving in full thrusts now, pinning your legs back against your hips with hands on your thighs. He grunts with each thrust as the stretch opens you up more, each stroke leaving your body tingling.
“Oh fuck.” you cry out.
“That’s it little woman,” he grunts. “See you are taking that cock so well. Ain’t trying to run from it now are ya.” He takes one of your hands and moves it to hold your own leg back so he can brace himself, hand planted just over your shoulder. You grab his shoulder with your free hand so you can lean up and watch his cock pound in and out of you. He props your head up more, “You want to watch my prick fuck up into you huh? God, the faces you make,” He buries his fingers in your hair tilting your head back. “Look at me,” he growls almost feral and you obey, meeting his intense lustful gaze, “Good girl now look over there at your man, look at how much he loves watching your pussy get absolutely destroyed.”
“That’s right, he loves this, now watch me fuck up into you.”
He lets you down so he can kiss you hungrily, shifting your legs so one is underneath him and the other hooked around his waist. Your cunt is making embarrassingly obscene squelching sounds as he slides back in and picks up his pace.
“I am- I am-”
“You gonna cum for me? What a good girl, come on baby girl cum for me, cum on my fucking cock,” he moans in your ear speed doubling. “That’s when the real fun starts,” he growls, biting your earlobe. “Your pussy feels so good squeezing around my cock like that.” Your body goes rigid as your orgasm tears through you. You shout out a startled moan when he keeps going. “Look at me with those pretty eyes.”
“Oh fuck, oh fuck! Oh FUCK!” you scream, unable to open your eyes as you try and turn away from him. .
“I said look at me,” he barks, grabbing your jaw in his large grip and turning your head back to face up at him.
“Okay please…” a long loud pleading sound leaves your throat as your orgasm tips over into over stimulation.
“Look at me and tell me what you need,”
“I just need a second big guy please,” you whine forcing your eyes open looking up at him with pleading eyes and he hums pulling out, you sigh in relief as the pressure drains. However he quickly flips you over, shoving a pillow under your hips before he’s sliding back into you. You lurch forward still overstimulated and he pulls you back by your hips.
“Are you running from me again little girl?” he laughs and you whine, shaking your head. “Good I would hope not, I haven’t even gotten to cum in that sweet little pussy of yours, would hate you to find out you’re a rude and selfish little brat now.” His thrusts are slow and fluid and you try your best to stay still.
“No, no, I’m trying,” you shake your head pressing your face into the mattress with a trembling whine, “It’s too much, It’s too much, I’m cumming again, I’m cumming” your voice rises frantic as Charles grips your hips and pounds into you harder. your legs pushing out and straightening in an overstimulated spasm, his cock slips out a little and he tisks landing a sharp slap on your ass.
“I don’t know, seems to me you need a lesson in manners.” Before you have time to think about what that means he is pulling you around so you are on the bed the longways and he can lean up over you and use the headboard for leverage. All you can do is moan and cry out as he jackhammers into you from behind, your back bowed in so far you swear your spine is touching your belly button and your body tries to escape the overwhelming pleasure. “I told you not to run.”
You are absolutely hollering as one of his hands comes down and pushes your head against the mattress. “That’s right, now you gotta take it,” he straightens up for a moment, thrusting deep and slow as he stretches out his back. “Say thank you,” he orders, squeezing your ass before his hips go back to their punishing pace.
“Thank you Charles,” you moan, voice undulating with his thrusts.
“You want to cum again on this dick, just like this?”
“Yes, yes Charles please,” he grabs your hand and brings it to your clit.
“Rub your clit for me, get yourself off, go ahead, this time I want you to turn…” Charles moves your bodies to follow his words as he speaks. “And look at Arthur, and I want you to tell him how good my cock feels, and I want you to thank him for letting you have it.”
“Ng, his cock feels so fucking good Arthur, thank you,” you whimper out as your orgasm grows near.
“Tell him thank you for sharing your pussy go on,” Charles slaps your ass and you cry out, unable to speak through the pleasure. He spanks you again, “Go on,” he spanks you a few more times before grabbing your hair and pulling your head back. “You are about to cum aren’t you, you seem to get real rude when you cum.” he slaps your face lightly but hard enough to sting and you let out a loud cry right in his face as your orgasm hits you like a train. You are practically screaming as he fucks you through it.
"No, no, no," you beg.
“Tell him thank you now, you Brat,” Charles laughs darkly.
“Thank you Arthur, thank you for sharing my pussy,” you whine.
“Good now fuck yourself back on me like the good girl you want to be.” he says slowing down then stopping, pulling almost all the way out but stopping with his cock head still inside you. You hear him spit again and moan bucking back. "That's right, such a good girl." He squeezes your ass again pulling your cheeks apart and you groan as he hits even deeper. “Keep going, find your rhythm,” he lets out a loud groan that has you curling your toes as you rock back, letting the impact of your ass on his hips push you back forward again. “That’s right, bounce that ass on my dick such a perfect little slut.” His hands stroke over your ass and down your thighs over and over, the sound of skin on skin lulling him into a trance and he nears his climax. Then in a blink he snaps out of it, slapping one side of your ass then the other. Stilling you with a firm grip on your hips. You cry out and he laughs.
“Yeah see, you were starting to get too quiet for my liking.” He pulls out moving up on the bed, sitting with his back to the head rest before pulling you up on his lap. He manipulates you like a rag doll and you are powerless to stop it. “Come here, come sit on this cock so I can fuck up into you, I want to hold you close as I release my cum deep in your tight little pussy.”
When you look over you are surprised to see Arthur hasn’t even touched himself, instead fully fixated on watching the two of you go at it like animals in heat, fingers steepled at his chin as if he is deep in thought.
“Arthur… you don’t want-”
“Oh I do but that’s not what this is about-”
“Nonsense, you won’t say it but I know what you want now.” Charles cuts him off.
“Is that so?”
“Oh yeah, you want the man who just ravaged your woman’s pussy to now come over and suck you off.”
You roll over to your side and pull a pillow up under your head so you can see better. You watch as Arthur gathers Charles’ silky black hair into his hand as Charles sets to work undoing his pants and freeing his cock.
Arthur pulls Charles head down pushing his cock past those lips making him swallow against his gag reflex. Charles meets his eyes, letting the other man hold him down until his eyes are watering. Charles coughs and pants when Arthur pulls his head up. He pulls against the blonde man’s hold to lean down and lick up the saliva dripping down his shaft, slurping up where it’s pooled by his balls.
“Oh fuck Charles’,” he let’s Charles have a little control for a few more moments before he’s pushing him back, releasing his hair as he stands. Charles looks up at him confused but Arthur only smirks.
“Oh what, you think I’m gonna let you rough up my woman,” he pushes his jeans down more as he moves towards Charles where he waits on his knees. A curious look on his face as Arthur takes himself in hand continuing his same even tone, “Let you fuck her, make her scream and them go easy on you? ” And fuck if you didn’t grow incredibly wet at the intimidating tone rumbling in his chest.
“Absolutely not,” Charles smirks, responding coolly. “In fact half the fun is going to be seeing you try and get even.”
“Well then get ready because I am going to choke you on this cock.” Arthur’s fingers slip back into Charles’ hair, giving a small testing tug.
“Bring it,” Charles mewls, intensity lost as Arthur pulls and twists his hair, maneuvering the larger man to where he wanted him to be.
His thrusts are shallow at first, Charles’ arms relaxed at his sides, but then as they get deeper he grips his hands into tight fists. “That’s it big guy,” Arthur grunts and Charles moans before he gags. “You can take it, I know you can.” Arthur angles his head back, thrusting more of his length down the other man’s throat. Arthur’s eyes roll back and his toes curl in as Charles’ throat tightens around him. Eagerly he begins to fuck his face and Charles has to move his hands up to Arthur’s thighs to keep himself steady. Just when you think Arthur’s about to tip over the edge you call out in a desperate whine and both the men still. Charles’ mouth poised just at the tip of Arthur’s cock and Arthur’s hand hovering just over the other man's shoulder. “I want you to cum in me, please I want both of you inside me.”
You can only cling to the bed sheets clenching your teeth as you ride out his overstimulating thrust. He had been intense in bed before but this was different from anything you had seen from him. It was carnal, primal, desperate the way his hips worked relentlessly towards his climax and powering through your own.
“Yes, yes, yes please Arthur please come inside me baby please oh god, oh god, Oh God!” your thighs tighten and tremble and your whole body quivers and shudders hands gripping back at Arthur, down in the sheets, anywhere you can grab as an almost painfully loud moan rips through you. “Fuck, fuck, fuck, please!” Arthur pins your hips to the mattress as he nears his climax.
“Almost there Darlin’, almost there, you just hang on.” and really it’s all you can do as he slams his hips down against yours with each of his thrusts. “I’m so close fuck.”
“You really liked that didn’t you,” you moan, “liked seeing Charles fucking wreck me with his cock.” At your words Arthur lets out a loud shout, stilling then thrusting jerkily, one hand pressing down between your shoulders as he comes harder than he thinks he ever has. He presses his forehead where his hand was and works on catching his breath, hands pressing your hips into the mattress and his hot breaths ghost down your spine. You look over and make eye contact with Charles who’s standing over the scene looking flustered but exhausted and sated. You pat the bed, moaning as Arthur slips himself out of you, and Charles slowly slips up next to you as you pull Arthur down to rest over you, stroking his hair as he rests his head on your chest. You lift your arm and Charles takes your wordless direction, laying his head down on your shoulder, your arm just barely wrapping around his broad back, fingers twisting in the ends of his long black locks. He finds it feels good being the one held… as much as you are trying to… and he falls into an easy doze, the last thing he’s aware of is Arthur awkwardly working the blanket over the three of you and you stretching to turn the light off.